Soft soils, wet soils, variable soils, and deep soils can all pose challenges in constructing foundations. In these cases, piles can be used to transfer a load to deeper and stronger soils or to spread a load along the pile's length. Different piling methods lead to different levels of noise and vibration as well as different rates of progress, spoil, and suitability to different ground conditions. This article will address the three most common methods in the UK: driven, bored and CFA piles.
When are Piles Used?
Soft and variable soils, wet soils, and deep soils can all be problematic in constructing foundations and justifying the use of piles. A thorough site investigation provides the basis for determining the type of piling that will be used. This is because what types of soil are present (i.e. cohesionless, firm, or dense), if groundwater is present, and what obstructions there are (i.e. bedrock or dense gravel) largely determine which type of piling will be successful.
Piles may be end-bearing where a pile rests on a firm stratum such as bedrock or dense gravel, or may be friction piles, where the soil along the shaft of the pile holds the load.
Driven Piles
Driven piles are fabricated in advance and can be of any of various materials, such as concrete, steel, or timber. Because they are fabricated in advance, their dimensions and quality are known. Some advantages to driven piles are that little or no spoil is produced and the rate of progress can be fast.
Drawbacks of using impact-driven piles include the noise and the amount of vibration created during the installation process. Impact driving can disturb neighbours and sensitive structures. As a result, this method may not be appropriate in urban environments, especially if you are working near old, delicate structures. Driven piles may also encounter obstructions such as old, hardened, and/or concreted soil that may stop or change the path of the pile. It may also be necessary to cut off or extend driven piles in order to reach final elevations.
Bored Piles
Bored, or replaced, piles are made by drilling a hole and filling it with concrete. To create the hole, the soil is removed using a rotary drill. The hole may be supported using a stabilising fluid or temporary steel casing, which may help maintain the integrity of the sides of the hole. After the casing is in place, a reinforcement cage is placed in the centre. Concrete is then placed to fill the casing. It is important to ensure that the concrete does not mix with the soil by using a tremie pipe.
Bored piles can penetrate a wide range of soil types and may be useful for substituting difficult ground conditions including, but not limited to, gravels, boulders, and some rock formations. This method may also be preferable to driving, due to the lower amount of vibration transferred to the surrounding area. It may also be useful to consider the amount of wet, heavy soil (arisings) that may be generated and the quality of the bottom of the pile, since it is not possible to see the finished product.
Continuous Flight Auger Piles
Continuous flight auger piles, or CFA piles, use a hollow-stemmed auger that is screwed into the ground to the desired depth. Concrete or grout is then pumped through the hollow stem while the auger is withdrawn, and the soil is lifted out with the flights. The auger systems support the borehole while it is filled with concrete. Once the concrete hardens, a steel reinforcement cage is inserted into the concrete.
CFA piles are favoured for speed, but are also able to support the borehole during the process, which makes it ideal for use with granular soils and sites that have groundwater, since an open borehole would collapse. CFA piles are also suitable for use in urban locations due to the low noise and vibration level.
As with all drilling methods, various limitations include the size and diameter of the rig used. Difficulties occur when attempting to drill through extremely hard layers and larger obstructions. Quality control is achieved through computerised monitoring of the volume of the concrete and the pressure and depth of the auger. A record is created of each pile while it is formed.
Choosing the Right Method
A number of factors are usually considered in deciding on the best piling solution for any given project. These may include;
Ground Conditions.
The bearing capacity of different types of soil varies and soil conditions such as high water tables require special piles. For soft ground, piles may be driven to the required depth, while for firm ground or rock, piles may need to be drilled.
Loads.
Heavier loads require larger piles and a more substantive base for the structure.
Convenience.
There may be constraints imposed on a job due to the location of the building site (e.g. near a hospital or residential area). Noise and vibration may be of great concern in such locations, and certain methods of piling may have to be restricted.
Testing.
Constant testing to verify the shape, soundness and integrity of the piles is standard practice in the industry. The installation of piles is documented and any problems are reported. Clear communication between the designers and specialists assist in a positive outcome for the project. Early determination of the best piling method, assures a timely and trouble-free construction of the project, particularly for sensitive neighbouring projects.
