All site managers have faced this challenge. You are evaluating a process, the plans submitted by the architect includes standard strip foundations, then the ground investigation report arrives at your desk, and there are suddenly conversations related to piling. Cue concerns regarding the budget and worries related to the timeline.
However, the challenge here is that piling is not always the expensive complication it appears to be. In some cases, it is simply the most reasonable option, and at times, it actually ends up costing you less compared to using traditional methods with ground conditions that are unreliable.
So when is piling actually needed on a site?
The ground investigation report is your foundational practice here, although there are some fairly obvious indicators before you even get that far. If you are constructing a building in the vicinity of a river, old drainage systems, or a region with a high water table, you are most likely dealing with a situation involving poor bearing capacity in the upper soil layers. Clay ground that is rich and will change with moisture is one classic example, particularly in a situation where there are trees nearby that will be drawing water from the soil.
Understanding the Made Ground
Made ground doesn’t mean positive. It can mean a lot of problems. Old industrial sites, old quarries, and even old Victorian gardens can hide a lot of levels, so they need proper examination. You may have a good load-bearing strata two, three meters down, but the upper layers cannot even support a standard shed.
Sloping Sites, Problems and Solutions. Sloping sites have their own challenges. Standard foundations require massive amounts of excavation and stepped trenches. Piling can often be more economical because you are going straight down to stable ground without having to move a lot of the hillside first.
Ground Investigation Report. These reports aren’t confusing on purpose, but they also aren’t the best reads. The positive or negative working parameters you are trying to find are the bearing capacity values, and the SPT (Standard Penetration Test) results. These are weak SPT values or weak layers of soil. But if the report shows uneven or variable layers across the site, that will be more negative because differential settlement will be more likely. There are many sites with a lot of variable layers of soil, but that is another red flag because differential settlement will divide the foundation. Cracked structures aren’t just going to be problems. They will be warranty claims for whoever owns the building. Lets face it. Buildings will go warranty claim faster than you can say “I’ve settled a warranty claim for the building” if they just go differential settlements. These are some old sites that we will be working with, but they will be made even better through the positive use of soil. When no piling is necessary
The good news is that lots of sites don’t need piling at all. If there is good clay or sand with a consistent bearing capacity across the footprint, no groundwater or contamination issues, and stable ground, then simple trench fill or strip foundations are more than adequate. If the ground can take the load without it, then there’s no reason to spend money on piling.
The mistake some make is that they assume piling is automatically stronger or ‘better’. That’s not the case, it is simply more appropriate for other ground conditions. If good ground is present, a custom engineered and properly built traditional foundation is just as effective as piled ones, and is also much faster and cheaper to install.
Archives and Background
While completing a housing scheme, reviews indicated the facility would need to be adjusted due to changing grounds and soil composition in the area. As a result, the design required foundation pilings to be added to the blueprints. Further investigations were performed in predetermined regions, indicating a majority of the foundation sites were stable. The houses were built using traditional foundation techniques in under 40 percent of the sites, while the rest were constructed using CFA piling techniques to meet the deadlines. The developers were pleased due to the lower budget and earlier deadlines. The construction crew was able to continue the other sites without delay due to the removal of excessive pile drilling equipment.
General Lessons
Conduct a soil investigation during the early stages. Attempting to estimate the initial survey for soil depth and condition during foundation prep is a false economy when trying to revise late costs and loss of access to needed equipment like pile drills to meet deadlines for certain soil conditions.
If the ground investigation suggests piling, talk to a piling contractor before completing the design. There is a variety of piling techniques tailored to different scenarios, and the most cost-effective solution will differ from site to site. CFA piling works well in most ground conditions. In confined urban sites, mini piling or restricted access methods make sense. A hybrid approach – traditional foundations where site conditions allow, piling where they don’t – is sometimes the best overall solution.
Making decisions based on actual ground conditions instead of assumptions is the key, and doing it early enough in the progams that it won’t disrupt everything else. Correctly timed foundation decisions will almost never be an issue. Foundation decisions will be an issue when the groundworks gang is waiting around for instructions.
